Submit your review

Create your own review

Average rating:  
 20 reviews
by Matt D on Classic Rarities
Informative Experience

I recently decided to have a coin collection that I inherited from my grandfather appraised to sell. Sat down with John and discussed the collection. He was very knowledgeable and easy to talk to. I left my collection with him for a couple days then he called me to discuss his appraisal and purchase offer. It was easy to complete the transaction and he offered to mail me the check to save me the trip.

by Kelly on Classic Rarities
Honest, fair and very friendly

Highly recommend Mr. Magavern III of Classic Rarities, LLC for all your coin needs. I recently inherited my grandfathers coin collection and knew that I couldn’t use or appreciate it as he did. I felt it was best to let someone else who truly loves coins enjoy the collection and I couldn’t be more satisfied and happy with my decision to go to Mr. Magavern. I could see and hear his excitement while looking over the coins. He was very honest with what things were valuable and what not so much. He was very accommodating and great to work with.

by Thomas Hunt on Classic Rarities

Very nice. They know what is worth tell you honest some one I would rely on for values of coins

by Sharon P. on Classic Rarities
Highly Recommended

John at Classic Rarities came highly recommended by fellow workers and friends for his knowledge and honesty. I can happily say he lived up to his great reputation and put my concerns at ease right away. It is clear he loves what he does and treats his customers the way he would want to be treated. I too recommend Classic Rarities.

by bill hanlon on Classic Rarities

Mr.Magavern was very informative and helpful while appraising my fathers coins.He"s very down to earth and enjoys helping people.Don"t go anywhere else!

by Steve McGuire on Classic Rarities
Very Knowledgeable

Mr. Magavern was very knowledgeable about all my grandfather's coins. He took his time to explain what made a coin valuable and why most of my coins were worth their silver value yet others were worth significant value. He was professional and offered us the most for our coins. Would certainly recommend him to my friends and family.

by Mark F. on Classic Rarities
Great experience

Working with Mr. Magavern at Classic Rarities was truly a great experience. He came out to my fathers house and was very patient with all of his questions. He took his time explaining the details of his offer in a professional and easy to understand manner. His knowledge of coins was quite evident. Many Thanks, Mark F. and family.

by Marcus on Classic Rarities
Pleasure to work with.

John is very knowledgable and is a straight shooter. Fair price on his offering and is great to have appointment time set for you and your task. Recommend Classic Rarities for your coin sell.

by Dave on Classic Rarities
Honest and knowledgeable

John at Classic Rarities was a pleasure to deal with and was quite knowledgeable about our coins. He offered the highest price of the three dealers I contacted. Many thanks Dave and Cheryl, Orchard Park.

Good Experience

John is the man to see if you don't know the value of your coins. He efficiently sorted my small collection and let me know the value. I was pleasantly surprised to receive more than the face value of the coins. Thank you, John.

Page 1 of 2:
"When knowledge & integrity matter with a name you can trust."